Billion Is That Really The Problem Environmental Sciences Essay

In the last 50 old ages, the universe has experienced population growing at a rate faster than of all time before. Given the lifting complexness of planetary interactions, resource depletion, clime alteration and poorness, against the background of a sustainable development pronunciamento, it is clip to see whether population is the chief beginning of the job. Dividing the ingestion and production tendencies into developed and underdeveloped universe, per capita informations analysis suggest that although population denseness of the underdeveloped universe is greater, its ‘ overall impact on universe systems is much less than the demand and ingestion of the developed. Empirical demographic informations suggests that the economic growing of the developed universe has led to leveling down of population but this leads to excess ingestion and effort on natural systems and handiness of resources. Uneven trade fluxes and distribution of the universe ‘s resources in footings of H2O, energy and nutrient farther intensifies this issue. There are strong economic benefits for both the developed and developing work to work jointly in making advanced solutions to resource direction and distribution ; such as comparative advantage and greater efficiency for sustained activities. Closed loop invention such as industrial mutualism provided assuring techniques to heighten resource public-service corporation and extraction efficiency, minimising waste and environmental debasement. Such procedures can be developed through utilizing systems-based thought which helps voyage the complexness and parametric quantities of varied planetary systems. Population remains as one of many factors and better weighting should be considered against background of other ageless environmental factors every bit good.

Population: 7 billion- Is that truly the job?


The cardinal thought of sustainable development was foremost presented by the Brundtland study ( United Nations, 1987 ) defined as ‘meeting the demands of the present coevals without compromising the ability of the future coevals to run into their ain demands ‘ . The challenge escalates when sing the current province split into two universes ; developed and developing. Both are at differential phases of economic and demographic growing ; where the population growing rate of developing states is presently 0.7 % versus 0.0 % and -0.4 % in industrial and passage economic sciences, severally. ( Food and Agriculture Organization, 2002 ) UN postulations indicate that the entire universe population will lift from 7,076 to 9,322 billion by 2050 ( Food and Agriculture Organization, 2002 ) . As Ehrlich ( Ehrlich, Kareiva & A ; Gretchen, 2012 ) suggests, if current universe ecosystems do non accommodate in readying for the rise it will clearly present endangering consequences for the extroverted planet with force per unit area on transporting capacity above what the universe could back up without hurt to its ‘ life-support systems.

Need essay sample on Billion Is That Really The Problem... ?We will write a custom essay sample specifically for you for only $12.90/page

order now

Taking ecological modernisation ( Dryzek, 2005 ) as an aim ; it is clip to see whether population is the chief job and if greater control over population growing would supply the solution. Given the fact that the richest 5th of the universe consumes 86 % of the universe ‘s resources, compared to the poorest 5th devouring 1.3 % ( World centric, 2012 ) it would do sense to measure the strengths of seeking to cut down resource-depleting ingestion and production forms of the developed universe.

This paper will first look at current forms of demand and supply through the H2O, energy, and nutrient link. It will discourse what weight should be given to population, ingestion and other economic dockets. It will so look at grounds why current industrial procedures and trade forms produce aggregate sums of wastes and offer a new option to presenting demand through closed cringle invention, via systems believing. Finally, it will discourse challenges and highlight countries for farther consideration.

The current planetary demand-availability tendency

Sing informations tendencies as per capita enables analysis on whether population as a variable has greater significance than ingestion as a driving force of environmental debasement. The graph in figure 1[ 1 ]represents per capita demand for five states ( United States ( US ) , United Kingdom ( UK ) , China, India, and Zimbabwe ) as a proportion of state handiness for H2O and energy ; and nutrient as an index of the mean planetary nutrient consumption of 2803 Calories per twenty-four hours ( United Nations, 2001 ) . This is compared against current population degrees as an index of resource use to entire population.

Comparison over base


Population Level

Figure: 1 Energy, Water and Food per capita Consumption as a proportion of Availability measured against Entire Country Population for United States, United Kingdom, China, India and Zimbabwe

Data Beginning: ( Food and Agriculture Organization. , 2012a, Food and Agriculture Organization. , 2012b, National Bureau of Statistics China, 2012, World Bank, 2012a, World Bank, 2012b ) ( United States Census Bureau, 2012, Office for National Statistics, 2011, Provisional Population Totals- India, 2011, United Nations: Department of Economic and Social Affairs, 2010 )

The consequences intuitively indicate that discrepancy between population and ingestion of H2O, energy and nutrient is largest in both the US and UK ( developed ) . China is the most resource efficient with population above per capita ingestion degrees. Both India and Zimbabwe ( developing ) eat dramatically less nutrient than the planetary norm, even though population for India is about four times larger than the US. Water degrees highlight over-consumption in all states and indicate H2O emphasis as a planetary cause for concern. The consequences suggest that although population denseness of the underdeveloped universe is greater, its ‘ overall impact on universe systems is much less than the demand and ingestion of the developed. Whilst uncertainness over the population flight is a factor, economic growing, size and part are all subscribers to environmental impact ( United Nations, 2001 ) and should non be considered in isolation.

Growth and population

Empirical surveies on population growing show a negative relationship between economic growing and population stabilisation ( United Nations, 2001 ) . This is based on classical demographic passage theory, where as a state goes through industrial revolution ; population first rises and mortality falls due social betterments such as better instruction, adult females ‘s authorization, wellness and birthrate determinations but so reaches stable, and even worsening replacing rates ( United Nations, 2001 ) . UN scenarios indicate the fact that population is non-exponential ; with all three scenarios of growing ( high, medium, low ) birthrate will lift at a smaller rate. ( United Nations, 2004 )

Fig 2: Estimated universe population, 1950-2000 and projections: 2000-2050

Datas: ( United Nations, 2004 )

Furthermore, the upward planetary economic growing flight as all economic systems finally go consumer societies exerts greater force per unit area on the environment and resources than population growing ( United Nations, 2004 ) . Alongside the systematic and moral trouble that comes with commanding population growing, it hence appears executable to give greater weight to economic growing ( via proficient and industrial inventions ) as instrumental to ecological modernisation, and as a practical measure towards inter and intra degrees of sustainable development.

In add-on, the uneven public-service corporation of environmental resources across the Earth combined with planetary heating has escalated menace of nutrient, energy and H2O security ( United Nations, 2001 ) . Figure 3 high spots this affect through distribution of works productiveness, H2O and land across the universe and stresses the urgency for rethinking current trade fluxes. Given that low-middle income states use 82 % of their H2O supply for agricultural usage ( United Nations, 2003 ) of which 45.2 % is on planetary exports ( Ross, 2008 ) indicate disparity between extraction of resources and where it is being consumed.

Fig 3: Urban, Dryland and Polar Systems

Beginning: ( Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2005 )

There are several economic benefits for population rise and income growing for the developed universe, as signified by the rise of imports from the developing universe ( United States Department for Agriculture, 2011 )[ 2 ]. Porritt ( Porritt, 2008 ) highlights the mentality displacement of developed economic systems bought by clime alteration extenuation and version which provides hope that if developed states work with developing states to turn to these challenges ; both universes will be able to make an age of sustained ingestion. Furthermore, Dryzek ( Dryzek, 2005 ) points out how ‘ecological restructuring of capitalist economy ‘ necessary for ecological modernisation and environmental preservation provides inducements for developed and developing states to derive competitory comparative advantages doing an drift for alteration.

Extraction and utility- the necessary displacement

In order to make degrees of sustained growing, it is necessary for antique ante and ex station betterments in efficiency on multidimensional graduated tables, to battle anthropocentric environmental debasement. In the UK, the entire sum of H2O lost through leaks 2009-10 was 2.8 billion liters per twenty-four hours ( Ofwat, 2009 ) . Food waste in America accounted for 31.75 million dozenss ( 12.7 % ) of the 250 million dozenss of municipal solid waste in the United States in 2008 and be approximately $ 1.3billion to landfill ( Buzby, 2011 ) . Demands for energy usage in the US are predicted to lift by up to 40 % by 2030 which will account for half of the fresh water backdown in the US today ( The National Academies, 2008 ) . To optimise on waste and resource efficiency, there is a pressing demand to pull off resource extraction, public-service corporation and distribution more holistically in order to guarantee the most Pareto efficient result. Voulvoulis ( Voulvoulis, 2012 ) explains how climate alteration is changing natural systems and bio-geochemical rhythms so sustainable development dictates the necessity to utilize systems based attacks in order to negociate lifting complexness with harmonising handiness to demand.

Industrial ecology and closed loop systems- a 3rd manner solution

As Bell ( Bell, ) describes, industrial ecology is based on the comparing between industrial systems and natural ecosystems. Life rhythm analysis is a methodological analysis which seeks to mirror natural ecosystems in order to look at cradle-grave industrial procedures and guarantee that along each measure of the production procedure ; waste and pollution inefficiencies are minimized through looping them into other procedures via recycling, redistribution and reprocessing ( Bell, ) . This enables positive feedbacks ; where ‘one procedure becomes another procedure ‘ natural stuff ‘ ( Bell, ) cut downing waste, increasing public-service corporation of natural stuffs and take downing overall economic costs ( Bell, ) . Furthermore, mixing smart extraction and smart use would supply an even larger multiplier consequence in footings of planetary resource public-service corporation.

On the extraction side there are multiple engineerings which are presently being developed to cover with better land and H2O use alongside pollution control. A promising illustration can be seen within the agricultural sector where no-tillage harvest production has revolutionized the agriculture industry ( Triplett & A ; Dick, 2008 ) . This is a procedure whereby harvests are planted in unprepared dirt and covered in 30 % mulch ( Triplett & A ; Dick, 2008 ) . The advantage of cultivated land is that it enables husbandmans to “ pull off greater sums of land with decreased energy, labour and machinery inputs ” ( Triplett & A ; Dick, 2008 ) . As Triplett describes ( Triplett & A ; Dick, 2008 ) , there are challenges with all new procedures such as control of plagues, trade good pricing, and fluctuating demand. Nonetheless, no cultivated land appears extremely sustainable in footings of minimising energy usage and maximizing land usage.

A good illustration on the production side is provided by the Dee Catchment Project ( Dee Catchment Partnership, 2008 ) . This saw the industrial mutualism of 13 companies in an attempt to protect and heighten the catchment of Dee Waterss every bit good as enhance system efficiencies. Through Restoration of H2O tracts, H2O pollution control and flood plain Restoration ( Dee Catchment Partnership, 2008 ) the companies have benefitted from ‘savings of ?5,750,000aˆ¦the net consequence was a decrease of 130,000mA? solid waste to landfill or incineration, 600,000mA? of H2O and 25,600 dozenss of air emanations ‘ ( Bell, ) .

A planetary attempt for close loop invention and systems based believing would supply strong foundations for smarter ingestion and production across the universe. With better extraction methods and public-service corporation of resources through systematic and infrastructural alterations to the current ecological theoretical account, there is impulse that population and economic systems can turn in tandem.

Challenges and countries for consideration

Whilst the 3rd manner demonstrates many assuring thoughts for the decrease of natural resource depletion and sweetening of merchandise life rhythms ; there remain a figure of challenges to transmutation, treatment of which is beyond the range of this paper. Greater experimentation is necessary to grok the feasibleness and inducement construction necessary for companies with the largest ecological footmarks to merchandise into closed cringle constructions ( Porritt, 2008 ) . Challenges remain with issues on fiscal trade good pricing, market volatility and skewed demand and supply motions ( Patterson, 2009 ) . Further challenges lie with short term mentalities and the demand for citizens to do thoughtful ingestion determinations adjacent with heightened environmental sensitiveness ( Dobson, 2009 ) .Shifts in such tendencies require better planetary policy ordinance ( peculiarly urban migration and megacities ) , supervising and rating in markets, instruction and finance ( United Nations, 2001 ) . However, as Voulvoulis argues ( Voulvoulis, 2012 ) , such complex challenges have a greater opportunity of success if viewed through systems believing ; as it combines ‘natural, scientific, engineered, or conceptual ‘ models to enable dynamic solutions.

Reasoning comments

The explosion of neo-capitalism and enlargement of globalisation has presented a overplus of environmental challenges which are transeunt in distance and clip. Disparities in development phases of growing and demographics, clime alteration, ingestion epochs, and resource scarceness have jointly contributed to intense force per unit areas on the universe ‘s carrying capacity. Much controversial argument therefore far has lay with population control as a looming solution yet analysis on per capita impact and forms of trade suggests that important impact lies with inefficient resource extraction, public-service corporation and ingestion behaviour. Industrial mutualism and closed cringle invention enable the continuance of ecological modernisation through enlargements of capital mold. Adoption requires a move to systems believing which demands attending in multiple dimensions, and while population should be factored into future direction and control ; better weighting should be considered against background of other ageless environmental factors every bit good.



Get your custom essay sample

Let us write you a custom essay sample

from Essaylead

Hey! So you need an essay done? We have something that you might like - do you want to check it out?

Check it out