An Understanding Gained Through Experience Or Study Management Essay

September 10, 2017 Management

The definition of Knowledge is ‘An apprehension gained through experience or survey ‘ ( Awad and Ghaziri 2004 ) . Knowledge is a societal phenomenon, which means filtering, categorizing, and understanding informations which turns into meaningful information, whilst doing inborn links for usage in a specific scene or a state of affairs.

To understand what is meant by cognition it is of extreme importance to understand the relationship and difference between ; informations, information and cognition itself.

Several readings ( Senge ( 1990 ) , Nonaka & A ; Takeuchi ( 1995 ) , Williams ( 2003 ) , Mc.Elroy ( 2000 ) ) start by saying that cognition is what makes us human. The ability to garner informations, construe it into information and usage it to derive advantage over a specific state of affairs.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Harmonizing to Nonaka and Takeuchi ( 1995 ) cognition can be classified into two major sets Explicit and Tacit. Explicit cognition is that which is concrete and can be easy transferred such as paperss, databases, studies, forums and libraries. Tacit cognition is a more abstract type of cognition but really powerful none the less. Tacit cognition refers to the cognition which is available in one ‘s encephalon. Each employee in the administration is a shop for silent cognition. Knowledge which the person homo being has developed by sing alone state of affairss, alone challenges both during professional and personal life.

In more item cognition can be made up of 3 chief classs ; facts, which are concrete and incontestable pieces of information and can be tested easy to a certain reply in the existent universe ; procedural regulations, which are chiefly gained through cause and consequence, and include conditioning from when we are yearlings, and eventually there is heuristic cognition which is gained through real-life experiences.

Organisational Knowledge ( OK )

Traditionally the cognition capital in an organisation was seen as an independent factor from fiscal or operational art. Land, stock, equipment, assets were founded and difficult assets, which can be evaluated, catalogued, depreciated and accounted for made the company a strong or weak one. However when industry was turning and competitory advantage was harder to achieve attending was get downing to be given to the existent cognition the company holds, such as fabrication procedures, expressions and techniques. Tangible resources such as land, equipment, stock and other were non being viewed as lending to competitory advantage which can be sustained on the long term. ( Bollinger & A ; Smith, 2001 ) stated that OK meets the strategic plus standard being rareness, value, inimitability whilst being non-substitutable

What is Knowledge Management ( KM ) ?

“ A procedure that helps administrations find, choice, organise, disseminate and reassign of import information and expertness acquisition, strategic planning and determination devising ” . Williams ( 2003 ) , pg.443, q3

In a broader sense KM is normally seen as the application of information engineering to ease the existent capturing of cognition. KM normally employs formal construction and processs to the capturing of that cognition normally by agencies of information shops and official certification. Having cognition stored but no agencies of sharing it serves no propose, therefore KM at a high-level besides includes how that cognition is really shared.

But can knowledge of all time be captured? When we remember that the development of cognition trades with informations which is transformed into information and that information is applied by people with experiences and patterns, it is merely so which is transformed into cognition, can knowledge every truly be captured by systems? The writer poses this inquiry as many already have. It is merely when worlds really use the information stored which is turned into cognition.

So, if the statement persists that KM is really pull offing cognition and research workers like Kuan Yew Wong ( 2006 ) province that cognition is merely inside the human head, is knowledge direction the direction of human existences and experiences? or truly merely information direction with a particular attending on application?

“ Knowledge remains inside the head of an single and human interaction is exploited to get it. Varied accents are developing and each of them is valid in its ain context. ” Kuan Yew Wong & A ; Elaine Aspinwall ( 2006 )

Knowledge direction replacing The Learning Organization?

A really interesting paper by Swan, Scarbrough and Preston gives a critical and analytical argument on the KM enterprise as both a craze and a Learning Organisation ( LO ) option. The empirical research carried out on ProQuest Direct ( PQD ) shows a rapid diminution in hunts for LO to a definite addition in KM hunts. However the most telling survey on page 672 ( Swan, Scarbrough & A ; Preston ) shows the matching keywords associated with both LO and KM and a definite result from this is the intension that KM is less people oriented more an administration and system oriented, whilst LO is still looked upon with connexions on preparation and human resources. LO was criticized for being excessively Utopian does this go forth KM as the sober opposite number to the political orientation of LO?

Mc. Elroy ( 2000 ) states that Peter Senge , Godhead of the OL motion and writer of the hugely influential book, The Fifth Discipline ( Senge , 1990 ) was asked about the emerging connexion between two of these three countries: KM and OL. Senge had antecedently viewed KM as little more than information indexing and retrieval, but now sees a new definition emerging. In its new signifier, Senge sees KM as trying to decide jobs which members of the acquisition society have been confronting in reassigning cognition.

Tacit cognition as discussed antecedently in this assignment is in the encephalons ( and memory ) of the human capital within the administration, hence for successful cognition transmutation one can non make without proper human relationship direction. If non adequate accent is put on the human side of KM than the exercising will be futile as the most of import thing is the willingness and methods of transforming cognition from employees to a KM tool or system.

“ cognition direction is dying to free itself of its overly technology-centric repute in favor of advancing the function it can play in fostering organisational acquisition. ” Mc.Elroy ( 2000 )

Why do we necessitate to pull off cognition?

Civi ( 2000 ) states that through the advancement of clip the lone existent competititive advantage that companies will hold will be determined by the cognition they hold.

Blair provinces that up to 95 % of an administrations cognition is Tacit cognition, therefore one can state that the bulk of an organisation ‘s cognition resides in it ‘s human capital. Ergo the chief and hard purpose for an organisation ‘s cognition is to reassign as much tacit cognition to explicit cognition as possible, where it is really possible.

Since cognition is a personal property on how people are construing the information collected it is of extreme importance for an administration to do certain that everyone is construing the information available right. Kuan Yew Wong ( 2006 ) has besides goes on to name benefits which a company makes fruit of when following an approporiate enterprise. Some of these benefits include betterment in efficiency, prouductivity, invention and reactivity.

In today ‘s every altering market topographic point the merely true plus of the company is the cognition capital of its human resources. Hence it is of import that the administration keeps the cognition within the company even if the human capital is non at that place, or has changed due to lay-offs, redundancies or merely employees decided to travel on. Apart from unplanned alterations to the work force, KM is a good for retaining the illimitable sum of cognition of people who are traveling to retire and likely have been working with the administration for a battalion of old ages.

A sound and feasible KM system besides means that new employees can acquire up to rush on the occupation at manus faster and normally avoiding the general errors which other employees before him have made.

Organizational Memory ( OM )

OM is a new construct, being written and discussed by academic equals at the minute. Walsh ( 1991 ) states that, at the clip, a batch of elemental constructs were fragmented and his work efforts to convey these fragments together to make a individual useable theory which can be discussed and criticized.

The writer included this subdivision approximately OM as it is apparently homogenous conceptually with the survey of KM. If KM as stated before is the act of transforming single tacit cognition into systematic explicit cognition within the administration, is n’t it adding to the organizational memory?

The definition of OM as stated by Walsh ( 1991 ) is that in general, an organisation may be independent of peculiar persons, but it should be recognized that persons get information in problem-solving and decision-making activities. This focal point on single cognitive activities as the cardinal component in the organisation ‘s acquisition of information reflects an active building of memory. However, readings of jobs and solutions vary with persons. The yarn of coherency that characterizes organisational readings is made possible by the sharing of readings. Therefore, through this procedure of sharing, the organisational reading system in portion transcends the single degree. This is why an organisation may continue cognition of the past even when cardinal organisational members leave ( Weick & A ; Gilfillan, 1971 ) .

Do n’t KM and OM have similarities in realizing the transcendency of Knowledge from the person to the organizational?

“ Memory is ‘the module of retaining and remembering things past ‘ ( American Heritage Dictionary, 1969 ) , and it is associated chiefly with persons. A widely recognized belief is that the acquisition, keeping, and retrieval of cognition and experience from keeping depositories ” Walsh ( 1991 ) , pg61, q2

As stated by Walsh ( 1991 ) the writer besides identifies with the statements about the jobs of theanthropism associated with the word ‘memory ‘ inciting ideas that administrations are populating things. However if the administration is deriving the cognition by capturing and hive awaying cognition is n’t the entity at the terminal of the twenty-four hours going anthropomorphous merely the same?

Tools for Knowledge Management transportation and gaining control

To the Knowledge Management Consortium ( KMC ) , a concern is merely another category of complex system. Pull offing cognition has nil to make with edifice computer-based depositories of facts and figures, they argue. Rather, cognition is the merchandise of natural invention strategies built-in to all populating systems.

Make the conditions in which invention thrives, they believe, and the development of new cognition will of course follow. Hence, unlike the work of Swan, Scarbrough and Preston, the political orientation harmonizing to the KMC of KM is really similar to the LO.

At the minute in the practical sense, KM has a batch of focal point on IT/IS systems which there chief purpose is to reassign and capture cognition. Some of these tools include, groupware, cognition bases, databases, in-house online preparation, computing machine based preparation and document direction systems, nevertheless really small is being put into focal point about the procedures and the HR facet of the administration.

This figure shows the Knowledge Life Cycle harmonizing to Mc. Elroy. As we can clearly see signifier this diagram this follows a similar lifecycle as OL, with cringle feedbacks, larning and making cognition as one remarkable aim.

The initial enterprise of Softual Developments Ltd. for Knowledge Management

I was one of the senior executives at Softual Developments between 2002 and 2005. Softual Developments Ltd is a immature company founded in 2002 and mainly trades with project-based work, considered as an SME on the Maltese Islands, Softual employs 21 full-time package applied scientists and 5 parttime package coders, a proficient manager, a concern manager, a general director and two full-time gross revenues executives. Softual Developments chiefly works in the E-commerce industry constructing e-commerce stores and content direction system sites for big to really big corporations.

The chief job that Softual encountered was the of all time turning abrasion rate attributable to the employees deriving the cognition and traveling on to larger companies. The direction had decided that the figure of staff was non traveling to be increased due to a two twelvemonth planned consolidation period, hence the direction was looking for systems and tools to retain cognition when experienced package applied scientists left the company and had to be replaced largely by juniors. The standard life-time of an employee at Softual Developments was between 1.5 and 2 old ages.

The board and managers decided to get down implementing a battalion of IT based KM systems, including A common portal, on-line preparation, computing machine based preparation ( CBT ) , a general cognition base and a specific problem hiting cognition base with jobs encountered and their solutions.

Although this was a good start to the KM motion by Softual Developments and as we saw from the old literature, such tools on their ain which are gaining control tools are merely a start without an organisational model and processes to back up the new KM enterprise, without floging any of the bing procedures it is bound to merely go an information gaining control system and non a proper KM enterprise which means that it will ne’er allow the advantages and benefits which such system should give.

“ There is a strong accent on change overing silent cognition to explicit but much less on developing new tacit cognition ” Williams ( 2003 ) pg. 444, q3.

By looking at Softual Developments and comparing this statement although the trouble-shooting cognition base was rather utile is was a mere information shop and it did non heighten cognition. Another job is that it was being noticed, that although the immediate job was being solved, the employee was non understanding the construct of the solution, therefore if the circumstance changed somewhat, although conceptually it was the same job the new employee would neglect in happening a solution ( which he should hold already known ) . Ergo, merely by implementing KM enterprises or tools that does non intend that we are developing OL.

“ Pull offing cognition has nil to make with edifice computer-based depositories of facts and figures ” Mc.Elroy ( 2003 ) pg.197 c1. q4.

Another job in comparing OL and KM is that the OL methodological analysis is really disconnected and abstract, when speaking about a Learning Organization, or OL, it is chiefly a methodological analysis, and thought, which every director or administration implements as they deem fit.

Since Softual was a company based on project-centric work, I had suggested that the company would implement PRINCE2 or ISO 10,006 which dictate processs and procedures for terminal of undertaking reappraisals. This would besides be a good enterprise towards OL every bit good as KM, nevertheless the theories at the clip did non back up this. Another error was that concern procedures were non officially changed to let clip for such activities therefore both employees and undertaking directors were rarely transporting them out, besides there was no official entering method of such meeting to reassign cognition gained from experiences.

“ Such reappraisals [ terminal of undertaking ] acquire barely any reference in much of the Organisational Maturity models-standards that measure how mature a company is in using Project Management. Cooke-Davies ‘ recent survey does non advert post-project reappraisals, nor does recent work on Organisational Project Management Maturity ( eg Kalantjakos17 ) ” Williams ( 2002 ) pg.444. q2


From the findings there are disconnected positions over KM between the research workers and the industry. Industry sees KM as merely a set of tools of informations gaining control, analyses, databases and informations excavation enterprises, whilst faculty members, including Nonaka and Takeuchi which are considered as the first existent cognition motion faculty members, had envisaged a companywide enterprise including, procedures, construction, HR and all the elements of an administration.

The academic position of KM is entirely compatible with OL since OL ‘s political orientation is to transform the whole administration, including procedure, construction, HR and processs to heighten larning within the whole administration ( including all the stakeholders ) . On the other manus as Swan, Scarbrough and Preston have discussed the engagement of KM normally attributes to a deficiency of focal point from the LO.

Complexity theory nevertheless stands to convey both motions together by accepting anthropomorphous analogies for an administration and accepting the an administration is in fact a living thing and delivery in line the two theories which are aimed both at bring forthing organisational broad cognition.

“ Practitioners of OL, see a difference between what persons know and knowledge held jointly by groups of persons ; single acquisition leads to single cognition ; OL leads to collective cognition. With this in head, they explain, struggle between the two in most organisations is bound to happen. But the tenseness between them is really seen as a stimulation for invention and creativeness. ” Mc. Elroy ( 2000 ) pg. 197, q4.

KM is undergoing a displacement in believing from merely capturing and airing to the entirely incorporate procedure non unlike OL. Mc. Elroy ( 2000 ) states that this can be seen as the second-generation KM with a displacement of focal point from the system to the administration.

“ This is a basically new trade name of KM, 1 that has shed its former preoccupation with information engineering as the stock response to all KM demands. KM now regards OL as its new best friend and, in visible radiation of its improved, more enlightened mentality, has given itself a new name: ‘second-generation KM ‘ ” Mc.Elroy ( 2000 ) pg.199 c2 q1


I'm Amanda

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out