Context Or Composition Describe What

By July 17, 2017 Cultural

Geographers in recent old ages have become concerned in the manner in which topographic point affects wellness ( Macintyre et al 2002, Shaw et al 2002, Cummins et al 2007 ) . There has been much ongoing ambivalency sing whether differences in population wellness can be understood through context or composing. Context and composing are two impressions which are correspondingly interlinked.

This essay will seek to specify the two constructs and analyze the underlying relationship to wellness inequalities. Context refers to where we live, and composing refers to who we are and how these factors contribute to, and explain wellness inequalities. Furthermore, this essay will show how context and composing are more complex than originally understood. I endeavour to demo that these two constructs should non be treated as reciprocally sole and alternatively how they are embodied as one, constantly interlinked, in order to explicate wellness fluctuations. Following, I will underscore the importance of topographic point in explicating wellness inequalities and demo how geographics has played a critical function in this. On a broader note this essay will seek to unknot the look context/place into two classs, societal and physical. By, analyzing these elements will imply how topographic points are complex and relational which can fluctuate over infinite and clip.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

The term ‘context ‘ is defined as ‘place effects ‘ and how topographic point can determine the result of an person ‘s wellness ( Macintyre, 2002 ) . It represents the features and physical characteristics of a vicinity in which people live. The characteristics of the environment relate to the societal, economic and physical constructions that influence the type and quality of the built environment such as the handiness of wellness and leisure installations, degrees of pollution and the societal environment. The importance of context, and how context can be used to explicate geographical fluctuations of wellness results, has burgeoned since the 1990 ‘s ( Ellaway & A ; Macintyre, 2010 ) . Macintyre ( 2002 ) uses the term collective, to reenforce context and highlight the socio-cultural and historical characteristics of communities.

Shaw et Al ( 2002 ) describes composing as the underlying societal demographics of an country, mentioning to the construction in footings of age, sex, ethnicity and socio-economic place such as societal category. To simplify composing is the societal make up of a peculiar country. Many different factors contribute to the spacial fluctuation of wellness. Who we are ; our socio-economic position ( SES ) , wealth, instruction and ethnicity can find whether we are more or less healthy. More late faculty members have argued it is non simply about who we are that can act upon our wellness but have looked deeper into where we live, and the results this can hold on our wellness. In understanding composing a geographical wellness fluctuation might connote similar types of people will see similar wellness, no affair where they reside ( pg 647 Curtis et Al ) .

The context and composing argument ascended in the 1990s as wellness faculty members recognised that area/neighbourhood surveies were non encompassed in explicating wellness inequalities ( Ellaway & A ; Macintyre, 2010 ) . It was argued that much of the informations comprised on population wellness was based on aggregative statistics centred on single features. Tunstall et Al ( 2004 ) criticizes geographical analysis of wellness because of ecological false belief and its uncertainnesss. Ecological false belief is the reading of an country or group of features as persons. An illustration of this is doing an unlogical premise that an country with a high degree of employment for immature people, will take to a immature people being employed in that country. Therefore, geographers may confront unfavorable judgment for such premises about people based on their vicinity entirely. They fail to take into history factors such as the size of topographic point, how these topographic points are constructed and the correlativity between an country and people.

Furthermore, Macintyre et Al ( 1993 ) theory was criticised by Slogget and Joshi ( 1994 ) who argued that composing of a topographic point is more important than context. Their survey explored the relationship between premature mortality and want. They measured the degrees of want through indexs of the per centum of families with auto entree, unemployed labor market and the proportion of work forces and adult females employed in societal category V and IV. The findings from the survey revealed that there was a correlativity between premature mortality and want which was explained by the socio-economic place of an person. The grounds “ does non corroborate any societal miasma whereby the shorter life anticipation of deprived people is farther reduced if they live in close propinquity to other deprived people ” ( Sloggett & A ; Joshi, 1994, pp.1473, 1474 ) . Want appears to be adequately assessed by personal or family fortunes, which are themselves associated with income and country based steps of want are non efficient replacements. For maximal effectiveness wellness policies need to aim people every bit good as topographic points ( Sloggett & A ; Joshi, 1994, pp.1473, 1474 ) . Nevertheless, Slogett and Joshi findings is skewed as the informations used was empirical and taken from a national consensus and failed to take many factors into consideration ( Macintyre 2002 ) . Equally good as informations from UK nose count contradicts Slogget and Joshi ‘s ( 1994 ) findings as decease tolls in England and Wales are greater in socially deprived vicinities. It can be said that although ‘several longitudinal surveies have related neighbourhood features to mortality incidence over clip, vicinity features have by and large been assessed at one point in clip ‘ ( Berkman et al, 2003, p. 52 ) . Shaw et Al ( 2002 ) farther specifies that census data merely reveals a snapshot of a vicinity and fails to recognize the mechanisms by which topographic points and single features affect wellness.

An statement made by some geographers that topographic point is important in understanding the fluctuation in wellness as it “ constitutes every bit good as contains societal dealingss and physical resources ” ( Cummins et Al, 2007 pg 1 ) . Recently a ‘rationale ‘ ( Cummins et Al, 2007 ) position of infinite has emerged in the discourse of wellness geographics. A rational position of infinite as a web and topographic points as ‘nodes ‘ , geographers such as Massey have contested the traditional construct of topographic point as ‘bound ‘ ( Cummins et al 2007 ) and stiff. Alternatively a rational position defines infinite as free and that populations of nomadic people who create battalions of connexions that are non separated by distance, nut by socioeconomic-relational distance ( Cummins et all, 2007 ) , that infinite is “ dynamic and fluid ” ( Cummins et Al, 2007 ) . The kineticss of infinite therefore, and the different ‘nodes ‘ people create means that people are effected and influenced by the features of non one, but a battalion of topographic points ( Cummins et Al, 2007 ) .

Furthermore, Haan et Al ( 1987 ) Alameda county survey in California looked at the influence of geographical country on hazard for mortality. Their survey found that higher degrees of race, gender and age mortality where more prevailing in people populating in poorness neighbourhood/area. The survey demonstrated the consequence of poorness country over single factors, proposing that step ining at the area-level via metropolis planning or economic development policies could be a possible public wellness intercession scheme ( Yen, 2006 ) . Alternatively, Waitzman and Smith ( 1998 ) found that although poorness predicted mortality for those under the age of 55 there was non the same happening in senior people, despite commanding single features. This survey demonstrates that consequences can change from one survey to another, and both composing and context can be argued as being more important than the other in explicating wellness fluctuations. The survey concluded that lower SES persons have “ poorer wellness because they tend to populate in countries which in some ways are wellness damaging ” ( Macintyre et al 1993 pg 217 ) . This decision is supported by similar consequences in other research. Consequences from surveies conducted in the UK besides found similar consequences, wellness inequality in an country were non interpretable by single degrees of want, such as the North- South divide, with the North holding poorer Health ( Macintyre, 2002 ) .

Frohlich et Al ( 2002 ) survey in Quebec, Canada looked at parts of compositional and contextual effects in apposition with behavioral and material factors to assist explicate smoking induction. The fluctuation was explained non merely by single features ( parents ‘ smoke position, instruction and pre-adolescent age ) , but besides by facets of the societal construction at the vicinity degree ( Frohlich et al, 2002 ) . This is imperative as it highlights the influence the local environment can play doing picks and ab initio the likeliness of undertaking a disease.

Macintyre et Al ( 2002 ) provinces there are many different decisions that can be formed from surveies associating to whether topographic point effects wellness. A ground for this could be due to the differing conceptualization and operationalization of country effects, as some of the factors categorised as country, may really step in with single features. Shaw et Al ( 2002 ) besides criticises the methodological attacks used to roll up grounds for wellness fluctuation and he uses the illustration of multi-level modeling. He argues that this attack affects the manner research inquiries are asked and as a consequence research workers are able to pull strings informations to confirm their findings. Likewise, Macintyre et Al ( 2002 ) criticises wellness research workers for deficiency of equal conceptualization, operationalisation and measuring of ‘place consequence ‘ . they argue ”place effects ” frequently appear to hold the position of a residuary class, an unspecified black box of slightly mystical influences on wellness which remain after research workers have controlled for a scope of single and topographic point features.

Macintyre et Al ( 2002 ) note that the differentiation between ”composition ” and ”context ” may be more evident than existent, and that characteristics of both material substructure and corporate societal operation may act upon wellness. He farther underscores that there are a figure of issues when explicating wellness inequalities in footings of context and composing as belongingss of persons or families that are used in many multi-level theoretical accounts are themselves shaped by belongingss of vicinity. For case, societal category is defined through a individual ‘s business ; nevertheless this measuring is constrained as it likely to be shaped by other variables such as the labour market economic system every bit good as educational background, lodging environment and school criterions. Furthermore, there is a deficiency of clear theorization on the nexus between countries to wellness, and once more merely a few research workers have looked at what peculiar characteristics of the societal and physical environment affects wellness. Again, Shaw et Al ( 2002 ) represent how context and composing should non be treated as reciprocally sole. To exemplify this, a individuals ‘ diet may be linked to the handiness of nutrient in that vicinity every bit good as holding the pick to devour it. Therefore demoing how context and composing are more complex, inseparable and may be interlinked. This illustration besides accentuates the trouble in seeking to recognize why wellness fluctuations occur and how to relieve them. Alternatively of handling context and composing independently, Shaw et Al ( 2002 ) argues that more demands to be done to turn to the balance between the two. Such as how well the difference in wellness fluctuation between the groups or countries is calculated for by population composing or by the context, in which those population reside.

Smith and Easterlow ( 2005 ) cogitate how academic geographers have concentrated on theories of topographic points above existent wellness issues such as mortality and disease. Cummins et Al ( 2007 ) besides echo a similar sentiment saying how research workers focused on researching whether topographic points do really impact wellness fluctuation. This type of concentration has unwittingly constructed the two separate impressions of topographic points ( context ) and people ( composing ) as reciprocally sole in understanding wellness inequality. However, they argue that a relational position of topographic point can assist us understand wellness inequalities. A relational position of topographic point argues that topographic points are multi-scale, topographic points have webs, topographic points are separated by socio-relational distance and topographic points should be defined as fluid and dynamic. They suggest there is a complex, relational, spacial mutuality, between people and topographic points, which varies across clip and infinite. They believe by charting an person ‘s personal geographics through multiple topographic points, this will assist us understand which environments are most outstanding for wellness and to what extent person ‘s features mediate this relationship.

Cummins et Al ( 2007 ) topographic point is related to wellness as it constitutes every bit good as contains societal and physical resources. Shaw et Al ( 2002 ) believe place/context can be disaggregated into physical and societal factors. Health can be varied by the physical environment in three ways, country, additive and point. An country beginning refers to the handiness of wellness advancing resources such as the entree to green infinite. Macintyre ( 2007 ) defines the construct of want elaboration, in relation to single or household want ( for illustration, low income ) can be amplified by country degree want ( for illustration, deficiency of low-cost healthy nutrient or physical activity installations in an country ) . This thought helps divert attending off from single determiners of diet and physical activity towards wellness promoting or wellness damaging characteristics of the physical and societal environment.

However Macintyre ( 2007 ) contends this, as it is non needfully true that poorer countries are more likely to miss the presence of wellness promoting resources. In a disadvantaged country in Glasgow, research carried out by Ellaway and Macintyre ( 2010 ) , found there was no nexus between greater entree to green infinite and wellness publicity. Factors such as perceptual experience of an country, safety and environmental jeopardies such as broken spectacless deterred persons from traveling out. Linear beginnings refer to environmental pollutants that are nomadic. For illustration Zmirou et Al ( 2004 ) shows a correlativity between exposure to traffic exhausts and chronic lung conditions such as asthma. Nonetheless Jerrett and Finkelstein ( 2005 ) research of air pollutants and wellness concluded that there was no obvious relationship between these two variables.

Shaw et Al ( 2002 ) breaks down societal factors into three classs touchable, societal and province. Tangible cloth can be described as the physical and material characteristics of an country for illustration the nature of the lodging, stores and installations available for people, which promote or damage wellness. Ellaway and Macintyre ( 2010 ) show the relationship between recreational installations and wellness is ill-defined. For illustration in Perth ( Australia ) , countries with low socio-economic position, had better entree to golf classs and beaches compared to the flush. While in America, there was a connexion between lower social-economic position, deficiency of entree to healthy nutrient and hapless entree to physical activity resources. This leads to the thought of obesogenic ; an environment that encourages high degree of nutrient consumption and discourages physical activities.

The importance of the two footings, context and composing to the geographical apprehension of wellness inequalities show that they are non reciprocally sole, but instead they are complex, intertwined and mutualist. Furthermore this essay has drawn attending to a figure of incompatibilities with predating academic literature that have investigated context and composing in explicating wellness inequalities. For illustration, the term ‘context ‘ is non defined clearly and the relationship between how it affects wellness. Health geographers may besides confront unfavorable judgment for ecological false belief whereby neglecting to see the relationship between context and composing. This essay has besides shown the importance of geographics in recognizing topographic point in wellness inequalities. Topographic point and context can be disentangled into two, societal and physical factors in order to explicate wellness inequalities. Although these factors have helped us understand how topographic point affects wellness, they excessively have been critiqued. This shows us that topographic point is multifaceted and relational, changing over clip, graduated table and infinite.


I'm Amanda

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out