Dicuss similarities and differences between Homer’s Iliad and the movie Troy Essay Sample

July 24, 2017 History

The ancient fable of Troy. recorded in Homer’s heroic poem verse form “The Iliad” Oxford ( trans. Robert Fitzgerald University Press 1974 ) has been retold in many other signifiers. the most recent being the blockbuster movie “Troy” ( 2004. Wolfgang Peterson ) . “Troy” is a basic retelling of the myth. missing many elements of the book therefore incorporating many inaccuracies. However. it entreaties to a modern twenty-four hours audience shortening and distilling narratives from the “Iliad” . “Odyssey” and “Aenead” and greatly cut downing the clip span of events. Some might state “Troy” is blasphemous. but could simply be viewed as another reading of events as “The Iliad” is. excessively. a secondary beginning of grounds. The texts differ greatly from one another but contribute to go through on valuable narratives to Western civilization ; all that is left of Grecian history.

As for the site of Troy itself. research workers have found that descriptions in Homers “Iliad” coincide with their findings. which is more than the film’s representation can state. Troy. or Ilium. existed on the West Coast of what is modern twenty-four hours Turkey. around 1200 BC. There are many beds of strata and grounds suggesting that Ilium was so attacked and burned to the land. Hittite texts besides make mention to the characters of Homer’s “Iliad” and a possible war. Archeologists are still oppugning their discoveries and seeking for grounds to back up or confute the many theories that evolve around Troy.

Between the book and the movie there are a wealth of differences. and similarities merely lie in the basic. unchallenged thoughts. “The Iliad” begins in the 9th twelvemonth of the 10 twelvemonth besieging of the Greeks upon Troy. whereas the film shows Paris taking Helen off from Troy angering Menelaus in the procedure. The Greeks canvas across the Aegean Sea ( in ships of a questionable 8th century design World Wide Web. archeology. org/onlinereviews/troy ) for retribution upon Priam’s Kingdom. with the aid of Achilles. Contending and bloodshed follow. culminating in the well-known wooden Equus caballus stealing onslaught and the combustion of Troy. This portion of the myth is told in “The Aenead” . as “The Iliad” ends with Hector’s funeral – a chief difference between the two texts.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Another obvious difference is the absence of godly intercession of the Grecian Gods in the movie. or so any direct grounds of their presence. As the Gods where what made the 10 twelvemonth war come to go through in the first topographic point doing “The Iliad” an heroic conflict of volitions. “Troy” falls short of supplying this resonance to its audience. and besides lacks credibleness in its secret plan. The accelerator of the war was triggered by Aphrodite when she promised to beautiful Helen of Sparta to Paris. She shields the lovers from Menelaus’s regard. and when the conflict between Menelaus and Paris takes topographic point. transportations Paris to the safety of Helens bedchamber ( Book 6 pg 106 ) . As the film can’t do this Hector has to salvage Paris alternatively.

Intervention by the Gods as the aid their favorite persons is a large subject in “The Iliad” . assisting to explicate how certain cases take topographic point. For illustration. King Priam walking into the Grecian cantonment seeking Hector’s organic structure. In “The Iliad” he is guided by the God Hermes by order of Zeus “The Wayfinder. showered a mist of sleep on them [ the lookouts ] ” ( Book 24 pg 432 ) . but in the movie Priam simply says “I think I know my state better than the Greeks” . This is where “Troy” deficiencies credibleness and demands to explicate how happenings such as these take topographic point. if they will non affect Gods at all.

Who kills who is another questionable factor in “Troy” . As mentioned. Hector intervenes and saves Paris from Menelaus. knifing him. In ancient narratives Menelaus returns to Sparta taking Helen with him when he plunders Troy. Another such case is when Brisies ( a slave miss for Achilles in the book. but a priestess of Apollo. Priam’s niece in the film” pang Agamemnon. He excessively was supposed to last the war and return place to Greece to be killed by his married woman Clytemnestra. Scenes like these are necessary to do “Troy” a simplified version of the myths. and convey play to the three hr movie so are possibly excusable.

Equally far as characters go. the movies star dramatis personae of Brad Pitt as Achilles. Eric Bana as Hector. Orlando Bloom as Paris and Sean Bean as Odysseus. makes for an interesting if non accurate portraiture of the antique supporters. Hector is possibly a small excessively perfect and baronial as he fights both his and his brothers conflicts with indefatigable courage and honor. He cries out to his ground forces “Honour the Gods. love your adult females and support your country” . However in “The Iliad” when it comes to the climatic battle between Hector and Achilles. it is Hector who flees “when he could keep his land no more. He ran…with Achilles hard on his heels” . before confronting his enemy. Besides in the “Iliad” it is knowing when he kills Patroclus.

Achilles’s lecherousness for power and his obstinate pride is good conveyed in the movie. He travels to Greece so his name will “live forever” . and upon his reaching defies Agamemnon’s orders. merely as in “The Iliad” : “I swear a twenty-four hours will come when every Archaean soldier will moan to hold Achilles back” ( Book 1 pg 6 ) . However the movie overdoes his sensitive side. if there is one that exists in the book. with his relationship with Brisies “The Gods enviousness us…you will ne’er be lovelier than you are now” as opposed to the “prize…sweated for” ( Book 1 pg 6 ) . His choler at Patroclus’s slaying. though he is merely a companion in “The Iliad” . non his cousin. is evident in both texts as he leaves Hector’s desecrated organic structure to “lie full-length in dust” ( Book 23 pg 421 ) .

A character with obvious defects is Helen. She flees volitionally to Troy with Paris in the movie ( this is disputed by Herodotus who claims Helen ne’er landed in Troy but stayed in Egypt. pg 107 ) . fearing her hubby Menelaus. continues to love Paris even when he fails in conflict. and the two flight in the terminal. In “The Iliad” she says to Hector “I want I had a good adult male for a lover…This one – his Black Marias unsound…he will win what he deserves” ( Book 6 pg 106 ) voicing her displeasure of Paris. Little of this is conveyed in the movie “I don’t want a hubby who can fight” . Her character is demeaned throughout the movie and does non back up the position that Helen of Troy was a powerful adult female in Grecian history.

The defects in the movie may non help in accurately stating the narrative of the “Iliad” but it does finally make more involvement in Greek fable. possibly spurring on a little fraction of the audience to farther pursue this involvement. and to read Homer’s work for their ain readings. However as Homer was born about three hundred old ages after the Trojan War took topographic point it stands to ground that the poet himself may hold made some mistakes.

Heinrich Schliemann was the first research worker to bring out the site of Troy. located on the Western seashore of Turkey at the entryway of the Dardanelles sound. Schliemann found that over 3500 old ages. beds had built up and the hill had grown to about 65 pess. He developed a practise known as stratigraphy. a signifier of clayware dating. enabling him to day of the month the assorted up strata.

Other archeologists continued Schliemann’s work to happen that Troy VI – the 6th bed of Troy from 1700-1250BC – had been the richest metropolis. Horse dentitions were found in this bed. and as the Mediterranean clime was non likely to hold bred wild Equus caballuss. this indicated that the Equus caballus had been a domesticated animate being in Troy. After the 1250BC bed is it evident that breaks occurred around Troy. doing the metropolis to fall on difficult times. Around 1180BC it was attacked and converting grounds shows that a war was lost by Trojans. preceded by a bed of ash. This day of the month was determined by carbon 14 dating and clayware stratigraphy.

The Trojan walls whose ruins still exist today had been erected around 1470BC. At first archeologists were puzzled by these as the country they enclosed was so little – merely five estates. but it was found that the munitions merely enclosed the bastion. while the remainder of the metropolis was expanded to the South. It is improbable the walls had of all time been 50 pess high as in the movie. because siege arms did non be at this clip. As for the lower city’s protection. a ditch merely broad plenty to halt chariots go throughing was built. so the invading ground forces would hold to scale it on pes while being attacked by Trojan bowmans. The ditch. along with the remains of a wooden palisade wall three hundred pess off has been excavated and Homer supports this relation of how Nestor. the great warrior designed the boundary so that Equus caballuss were “brought up short on the border of the ditch and stand neighing in fear” .

Another research worker. John. C. Kraft ( “Troy” World Wide Web. udel. edu/PR/udaily/2003/troy030303. hypertext markup language ) . has found descriptions in “The Iliad” which match the geographics of the site. although the landscape had changed over clip. He believes that the Greek cantonment and ship station were in
position of one another and that Homer supports this “For the beach. though wide. could non incorporate all the ships…so they filled the long oral cavity of the shore between the enveloping headlands” . The movie excessively shows the ships in such rows. but fails to gain that holding the Sun rise over them. up from the Aegean Sea. means it would be raising from the West. This is a big inadvertence.

Many inquiries remain as to how the Trojans defense mechanisms were broken down. An interesting theory affecting the God Poseidon has arisen: there is grounds of temblors happening in the assorted strata degrees. which may hold been the ruin of the Trojans after a 10 twelvemonth besieging. and Poseidon was God of both temblors and Equus caballuss. Thus it follows that this is how the great Trojan Horse myth came about ( “Troy – Ancient Myths and Unsolved Mysteries” National Geographic 2004 ) .

Further diggings around Troy show links between the Trojans and the Hittites in the Late Bronze Age. A ‘Standing Warrior’ figure was found at Troy ; others of its type have been found at Hittite sites. More disclosures have resulted from this ; in a Hittite text dated to 1280BC there is a list of three Gods: Appaliunas. “The Storm God of the Army” and Kaskal. Kur. “Appaliunas” closely resembles “Alexandros” – Paris prince of Troy. or Apollo. God of the Trojans. Other Hittite paperss show links with Homer. such as “steep Ilious” and a Luwian cult vocal “When they some from steep Wilusa” about a great struggle. perchance even war. ( “Homer and Troy” hypertext transfer protocol: //www. basarchive. org/sample/bswb/Browse. asp? )

There is ample grounds to demo that a Trojan War did happen. and that Homer did look upon the site as his descriptions of the landscape are so accurate. However the myths environing the war and its events are unfastened to guess and any grounds pieced together on these would be circumstantial.

Homer’s “Iliad” and Wolfgang Petersons “Troy” are two different retellings of a myth that has been carried down for centuries. they portion basic similarities and doubtless both contain inaccuracies when compared to the archeological grounds at Troy. The movie brings to a modern audience the admirations of Grecian History. and inspires involvement in Homer’s “Iliad” which in bend provides its readers with a more in-depth representation of events.


I'm Amanda

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out