Inseparability Of Production And Consumption Marketing Essay

July 17, 2017 Marketing

Inseparability of production and ingestion refers to the constructs of interaction and service brush. The procedure of coincident production and ingestion involves the presence of clients, the client ‘s function as a co-producer, customer-employee and customer-customer interactions that makes it alone from a merchandise ( Shostack 1977 ) . Research workers frequently refer to the clients as ‘partial employees ‘ in a service puting. During co-production, client involves himself in self-service ( self check-in ) , utilizing engineering and machines offered by the service supplier ( air hoses ) .

2.1 Service brushs

During coincident production and ingestion, it is the ‘service brushs ‘ , that are the critical minutes of truth in which client frequently develops a perception/ attitude about the concern ( Bitner et al. 2000 ) and creates a distinction from other rivals. In the air hose industry, these service brushs are on which the administration, either thrives or dies based on client ‘s rating of their service. And the successful administrations take it a measure farther to heighten their nucleus or indispensable characteristics with drawn-out or enhanced characteristics.

Service brushs can take topographic point across a scope from the traditional face-to-face ( check-in, cabin crew ) , telephone ( telephonic cheque in, booking tickets ) , and in conclusion through the cyberspace ( web check-in, booking tickets ) and at every point the air hose industry thrives to do it easier and comfy ( less clip devouring ) for the client. A successful administration is which that exceeds the client ‘s outlooks ( heightening characteristics ) and non merely run intoing their outlooks ( nucleus characteristics ) . But Harris et Al. ( 2003 ) suggests that if the nucleus characteristics are non met by the air hose industry, it is that leads to client dissatisfaction. He besides suggests that merely 5 % of the unhappy clients complain to the service suppliers, therefore doing it hard for the service suppliers to turn to the issue. What intrigues even more is that the 95 % of the clients, who do non kick, speak negatively about the service to their familiarities. . However, when disgruntled clients do kick and the job is resolved to their satisfaction, they are really likely to return. The grounds for dissatisfaction may change across long waiting lines at check-in or engagement counter, unqualified forces, insecure web site and so on and so forth.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Bitner et Al. ( 2000 ) suggests that in the air hose industry nucleus factors vary from friendliness of the staff, cognition about the service, efficiency, and quality service, healthful and safe environment. But to make distinction from their rivals these administrations, supply added or heightening factors and those include concierge service, reserves, siting by host, lounge/ hotel installations for delayed flights and so on and so forth. Today in the air hose industry, companies do offer most of these characteristics but it is noted that the cost additions for a more enjoyable experience. For illustration, an Air India flight provides cheaper flights merely hardly run intoing the nucleus characteristics, but Emirates for the same path provides expensive flights with a varied drawn-out factors. What companies like Air India could make to supply a better experience would be to remove/ cut down the unsatisfactory experience ( upgrading a client, complimentary repast in instance of delayed flights, trained forces to cover with unhappy clients ) .

2.2 Shostack ‘s Models

Based on Shostack ‘s Continuum, the bundle Tours ( Flights+ Hotels ) offered by most air hoses, organize the intangible terminal, even though there are touchable terminals to be considered. Shostack ( 1977 ) suggested that there is no element known as a pure service and that there is ever a continuum between the touchable dominant goods and intangible dominant services. The air hose industry, the touchable elements include the insides of the flight, nutrient, place and besides the overall in writing continuity from purchasing tickets to the attender ‘s uniforms ( Shostack 1977 ) . Even though the air hose industry is intangible dominant, different market sections require different elements to do it an experience for them.

Say for illustration in the instance of Virgin air hoses they have three tailored going experience for three different markets.

In the instance of students/ backpackers or during bad economic conditions, it is elements such that ‘reaching from one finish to the other ‘ or a ‘no frills ‘ flight would be of accent on the atomic nucleus ( inexpensive flights+hostels, bed and breakfast )

In the instance of concern travellers, it would be schedule frequence along with comfort would be most of import ( a comfy travel+ hotel with cyberspace, office installations ) .

Last for tourers ( with households ) , it would be unison of in-flight and post-flight services ( hotels ) that would be of paramount importance ( Comfortable flight-but non excessively expensive+hotel near a tourer finish )

But in the instance of touchable elements the assorted markets demand otherwise. For illustration, for flights like Air Asia, which offers low cost air travel, the travellers are non provided certain touchable elements such as nutrient and imbibe in-flight. But these air hoses merely cater to travellers who wish to go on a limited budget.

So the challenge for other houses is to make an experience for each market, so that it would organize an experience for each of them as each of their demands differ from another. The challenge is to understand how consumers perceive a certain service and what as a house they should make to pull off and run into the outlooks ( Lovelock and Gummesson, 2004 ) .

Shostack ( 1977 ) defined a theoretical account that was termed as ‘total market entity ‘ where she argues that a alteration in one component may alter the entity on a whole or partial footing. Say for illustration in an air travel at that place, it is a unison of both touchable every bit good as intangible factors. And some touchable factors merely act as service elements/evidence.

1. Peripheral grounds: this refers to a touchable factor, which no or small value if it exists on its ain. It is portion of the service or is required to see a service. For illustration a flight ticket, does non intend anything on its ain, but is indispensable for completion of a service.

2. Essential grounds: Consumers do non have these and can be on its ain as its extremely dominant in its impact on a service purchase. An illustration of an indispensable component provided by Shostack is the DC-10 aircraft, which was involved in a few clangs in the seventiess. But even though all the issues were resolved, US refused to wing in a DC-10 aircraft that finally led to trashing them off wholly.

This theoretical account nevertheless does non demo how a service maps and this is explained utilizing another theoretical account by Shostack-Service Blueprinting. It has been developed to cover with processed, Acts of the Apostless and flows and in ( fig 4 ) , a design for air hose travel has been presented under how air hoses try to cut down variableness

2.3 Service experience

Every clip a client is interacting or holding a service brush, a service experience is taking topographic point and because coincident production and ingestion takes topographic point, the client largely experiences the service in the house ‘s physical milieus ( Groove and Risk, 2001 ) . In some instances the degree of engagements between the client and the employees of the administration is high and in some instances really low and some with no engagement at all. And the nature of physical environment depends on the nature of service every bit good as service experience. What the houses aim to make is do net income while making a satisfactory or alone service experience.

What determines an experience is besides the nature of the physical infinite. For a high engagement instance, ( for illustration, self check-in, sofa services, web site ) client satisfaction can be enhanced, by originative usage of physical design ( Bitner 1992 ) . In the 2nd instance, where the employees play a major function, and where clients have less or no contact ( cock-pit, cargo forces ) with the service forces, the physical environment should be to actuate, fulfill the employees, as no or few clients will see that. In the last instance, where there both clients and employees interact in the same environment at the same degree ( antagonistic check-in ) , the servicescape is the most complex as it needs to appeal to the clients but at the same clip be expeditiously actuating the employees ( for illustration, at a check-in the counter needs to look clean and efficient to the clients, but besides comfy for the employee-nice seats, environment ) . Thus the environment should be impersonal to appeal to both clients and employees.

Other than the physical environment, it is the client to whom the service is delivered is what is of import. Like mentioned earlier, different client have different demands and it varies based on their gender, age, societal position and so on and so forth. For illustration, a client ‘s demands going on concern category will change from that from one going in economic system category and the service supplier needs to run into each of their demands. What usually happens in the air hose industry is that the client going on concern category is more ‘looked after ‘ than the economic system category traveler. This would intend that it creates a negative service experience for the traveler.

2.4 Service Quality

Service experience is defined by the quality of service provided by the air hoses.

Based on this service quality, a conceptual theoretical account by ( Parasuraman 1988 ) , defines the spread between what the clients expect and what is provided. From this theoretical account, it can suggested that to make a better service brush for the clients:


This represents the nothingness between the perceptual experiences and outlooks between the seller and the consumer. The key is to understand what the client expects instead than organizing a perceptual experience of what they might desire. Parasuraman et Al. ( 1988 ) suggests that this nothingness can be filled if sufficient market research is done prior to offering the service. For illustration, if an air hose house is to happen out what a peculiar mark market is looking for, before offering enhanced factors.

Gap 2

This refers to the nothingness between what the company perceives and the service quality specifications. For illustration, low-budget flights like Air Asia advertise that they provide in-flight amusement, but the quality is limited ( all riders view the same programme on a individual telecasting set )

Gap 3

This is the nothingness between quality specification and service bringing. For illustration in the instance of few Asiatic air hose companies, the quality of service provided would be accepted by the place state. But outside the place state, the quality specification may non be on par with what the clients expect. For illustration, in India, Kingfisher airlines claims to supply universe category travel experience to its clients. Even though the service provided is perceived to be on par with top air hoses in India, the quality of service offered is nowhere close to air hoses such as Singapore Airlines, Thai Airways etc.

Gap 4

This relates to the nothingness between the criterion of quality promised and the service delivered. Thai airways has positioned itself has an air hose that brings together quality every bit good as hospitability ( ‘Travel with the Thai touch, Smooth as Silk ‘ ) . But what raised issues and led to negative promotion was when their forces were found to be ill-mannered to riders. This led to a wholly contradicting image of what they claim to be to what is delivered.

2.5 Differentiation

To make a distinction from their rivals, air hose houses use the Porter ‘s Generic Strategy Model ( 1980 ) :

Cost Differentiation

Cost Leadership

( No Frills )

Rynair, EasyJet, AirAsia


( Premium monetary value for superior quality )

Singapore Airlines, Emirates

Cost Focus

( Differentiation merely for a peculiar mark group )

Kingfisher Red-low cost Business travel

Differentiation Focus

( Premium monetary value for superior quality for a little mark group )

Concorde flights used by BA, Air France

A380 flights-Singapore air hoses, Qantas, Air France


Narrow Broad

Fig 1: Porter ‘s Generic Model for the air hose industry

Airlines Prosecuting cost leading scheme

Airlines prosecuting an integrated scheme ( some stuck in between )

Airlines unable to accomplish either a cost leading or distinction scheme

Airlines prosecuting a distinction scheme

High Menus

Low Menus

Low Service Level High Service Level

Fig 2: Airlines Realized Business schemes ( adapted from Dostaler, Flouris 2004 )

Using Fig 1 and fig 2, Porter ‘s Generic scheme can be explained as:

Cost Leadership

Cost leading refers to deriving competitory advantage and giving your company an border over the others. This can be attained in two ways: First increasing net incomes by cut downing costs. Second increasing market portion by bear downing low monetary values.

Airlines such as Air Asian, Rynair have chose to cut costs to a lower limit, therefore enabling to bear down the clients low monetary values. This tactic helped them derive market portion, and besides have all their flights to the full booked, which leads to farther decrease in cost. But where they did compromise in on the in-flight and other services. For illustration, these air hoses do non even provide H2O in the flight ; one is expected to purchase them, free siting etc helps them monetary value their tickets low. Smaller air hoses even supply merely few paths at cheaper monetary values than their international challengers.

But the hazard if when rivals follow suit and hence houses should look for agencies to continuously cut down costs.

Differentiation Scheme

This involves doing 1s service different and more alone. This could be achieved by air hoses in footings of their aeroplane types, costs, trade name image etc. Singapore Airlines, Emirates have portrayed this image of doing travel an experience with their superior quality. But as Porter ( 1980 ) argues that for a company utilizing distinction scheme, they would incur extra costs for research, development, invention every bit good as advertisement, which are usually recovered from the clients.

Focus Strategy

Airlines utilizing focal point scheme focal point on a niche market and this could be a alone low cost air hose for a mark group or high-end monetary value for another mark group. For illustration, the A380 aeroplanes used by Singapore Airlines and Emirates charge a premium monetary value of ?3600 for Business Class travel on Emirates from Heathrow to Dubai. So this is for the mark group who like to go with a lap of luxury with pool tabular arraies, watering place, Internet, sofa country etc during their flight of less than 7 hours.

There is really less competition in markets where focal point schemes are used. But the hazard is when the niche will vanish and when the concern and client penchants change over clip.


One other characteristic of services selling is its heterogynous nature and administrations strive to cut down the variableness that would take to constructing a strong trade name. The purpose is to pass on a relentless image and message to its clients at different topographic points and different times. Service Variability can take topographic point in different ways.

Variations in external Conditions -weather, herding and differences in service locations

Variations in service delivery- client interactions with employees

Variations in client perception-customers ‘ perceptual experience of a service may differ from topographic point to topographic point and with clip excessively

The figure below shows the causes and effects of service variableness in any administration.

High Level of perceived hazard for purchasers

Trouble in showing an image of consistent quality

Trouble in developing strong trade names

Servicess are produced ‘live ‘

Frequently leads to no opportunity to rectify errors before ingestion

Frequently reliant on imperfect human inputs

May be hard to draft the service

Variability of Service

Fig 3: Cause and Consequences of Service Variability

The issue of variableness leads to difficulty in achieving a unvarying end product particularly in services that require a batch of human interaction. Say for illustration, we still have non developed engineering to extinguish the demand of worlds wholly. Airlines do non utilize automatons to replace the human cabin crews as one human interaction is indispensable and secondly some engineerings are excessively expensive to follow suggest that behaviour varies non merely amongst different employees but besides amongst the same employee on different yearss and with different clients ( Lovelock 1983 ) . And even though scripting and blueprinting is used to cut down variableness, it still has its demerits.

To supply a good service every bit good make an experience for the client and to guarantee reduced service variableness, the air hoses use the following techniques:

1. Employee Training

As employees are portion of any service provided, most air hose houses have a strict choice and preparation procedure. For illustration, Singapore Airlines hires staff who fit in with the ‘Singapore Girl ‘ image and portray the same values as the house does. Firms who invest a batch in choice and preparation procedure largely offer higher quality service than others. Air India does non supply changeless preparation to its staff and hence issues originate when the staffs do non pass on a consistent message. Staff hired should be able to sympathize with the clients every bit good as trained to cover with different types of unsated clients. Besides it is taken attention to see that the staff matches the cultural differences of the state they are based in.

2. Scripting

Most air hoses have pre-determined books for each type of service brush, which consists of either verbal responses or series of actions. The use of verbal books is common while booking a ticket or asking about a service. Like for illustration, when a client calls a call Centre for a question, they usually have a book, which goes by:

“ Good forenoon, Thank you for naming Malaysian Airlines. My name is Ben and how may I assist you? ”

Similarly a written message is used after a call or as an apology. In the instance of written actions, it would how all cabin crews, follow the same actions once riders are in the flight.

All messages and actions are scripted so as to guarantee a consistent image, message every bit good to guarantee that the information is communicated at all times. But this has its restrictions in footings of how at times forces feel restricted from offering superior service based on their opinion.

3. Blueprinting

Shostack ( 1982 ) suggested that drafting allows quantitative description of critical service elements, such as logical sequences of actions and procedures, clip that happen at a topographic point of service bringing. It besides defines actions for the topographic point of interaction ( front-line ) every bit good for events taking topographic point beyond the line of visibleness. ( Zeithaml, Bitner et Al. 2006 ) define service blueprinting as a tool for at the same time picturing the service procedure, the points of client contact, and the grounds of the service from the client ‘s point of position. With this description, the writers emphasise the different systemic beds overlapping in a service, from the bed of client interaction and physical grounds to the bed of internal interaction within the service production procedure. The figure 4 below shows a service drafting for an air travel.

Fig 4: Blueprinting for Air Travel

Airport exterior Parking

Baggage claim


Gift stores. Toilets






Gift stores. Toilets


X-ray machine

Metal sensor

Conveyor belt

Computer/ recognition card




Airport exterior Parking

Online/ web site


Check plane

Metal sensor

Conveyor belt

Conveyor belt

Remove bags


Serve client

Greet client

Send off client

Load bags on plane

Check Passenger

Greet & A ; take bags


Leave airdrome

Pick up baggage


Exit plane


Board plane

Check in

Delay at gate

Security cheque

Arrive at airdrome


Support Process

Contact Person

Wing Onstage


Physical Evidence

4. Quality Audited accounts

This is done to supervise the consistent quality provided by the air hoses. Ground service analysis covers fining, check-in, security, sofas, embarkation, goings, transportation, reachings, and corporate stigmatization. Onboard service analysis is a elaborate and complex Qualitative rating of all merchandise and service bringing elements – nucleus merchandise criterions, service efficiency and critical factors of staff service bringing. IATA carries out frequent safety audits.

5. Quality Awards

Airlines frequently advertise the awards they have received for their superior quality. These awards are recognized worldwide and guarantee that these air hoses provide first travel experience for their travellers. For illustration, in 2009, Singapore Airlines was awarded the Airline of the Year award for its superior quality and safety. These information may non be excessively relevant for the clients, it merely adds adequate promotion to do consumers recognize how one offers superior service than another therefore motivating them to seek these air hoses on their following travel.

6. Service Recovery

However thorough an air hose is on its quality and service provided, there would still be occasional bugs. And a characteristic of any service is its heterogenous nature, where each service brush is different from another one. Berry ( 1995 ) argues that companies do non authorise front line employees to work out jobs instantly.

A service failure does non automatically take to a lost client. But one time an issue is identified, if it is dealt with quickly and the right actions are taken to guarantee that the client is satisfied, so it largely would non take to a lost client. But in instance of a major issue, the client might seek fiscal compensation.

7. Customer Retention

Parasuraman et Al. ( 1985 ) suggests that even though there is a positive relationship between service quality and client trueness, above a certain degree, extra betterments in quality do non hold farther impact on client keeping as there is no point in increasing quality costs if it can non be passed down to the clients.

The variableness of services poses a high menace when it comes to trade name edifice, but since worlds are an built-in portion and can non be eliminated wholly, stairss are taken to supply better preparation, motivate and promote employees as they all form portion of the service brush. As Lovelock and Gummesson ( 2004 ) suggests that public presentation is less variable when machine-intensive engineerings are used.

So as to cut down the effects of service variableness, air hose industries have adopted the usage of engineering so as to cut down if non extinguish the factor of human mistake. These include:

Use of computerised system alternatively of telephone operators.

Use of self-check in Kiosks at airdromes, nomadic check-in ( SSTs-Self Service Terminals )

Using web site to book or amend tickets.

The other dimension of variableness is the extent to which a service can be altered to run into the demand of single clients. Servicess that are manufactured for a big figure of clients are hard to be customised like in the instance of air travel, but can be customised in peculiar countries. For Example scheduled air hose service is extremely standardized in design but offers faculties for custom-making specific elements, such as alternate agendas ; service to or from different airdromes in the same metropolitan country ; different categories and monetary values ; place location ; and a choice of drinks, nutrient, and other comfortss.

But with the development of engineering, industries particularly the air hoses are following engineering every bit far every bit possible as with lifting competition there is no room for mistake. But non utilizing worlds at all is impossible. So as Jim Collins said: ‘people are your most of import plus is incorrect. The right people are your most of import plus ‘ .


Berry, Leonard L. ( 1983 ) , “ Relationship Marketing, ” in L.L. Berry, G.L. Shostack, and G.D. Upah Emerging Perspectives on Services Marketing. Chicago: American Marketing Association, pp. 25-28.

Bitner, M. J. ( 1992 ) , “ Servicescapes: The impact of Physical Milieus on Customers and Employees ” Journal of Marketing. Vol. 56, pp. 57-71.

Bitner, M. , Brown, S.W. , and Meuter, M. L. ( 2000 ) . “ Technology Infusion in Service Encounters ” Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science. Vol. 28, No.1, pp. 138-149.

Dostaler, I. and Floris, T. ( 2004 ) . “ Business Strategy and Competition for the Future in the Airline Industry. ” Airline Magazine. No. 28, pp. 1-4.

Harris, K.J. , Bojanic, D. , and Cannon, D. ( 2003 ) . “ Service Encounters and Service Bias: A Preliminary Probe ” Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Research. Vol. 27, No. 3, pp. 272-290.

Groove, S and Risk, R. ( 2001 ) , “ Service theater: An analytical model for services marketing ” in Lovelock and Writz ( 2004 ) pp. 78-87.

Lovelock. C ( 1983 ) ‘ Classifying Servicess to Derive Strategic Marketing Insights ‘ , Journal of Marketing, Vol.47, pp. 9-20.

Lovelock, C. and Wirtz, W. ( 2004 ) , ‘Services Marketing, People, Technology, Strategy ‘ , USA, Pearson Prentice Hall

Lovelock, C. , and Gummesson, E. , ( 2004 ) . “ Wither Services Marketing? In Search of a New Paradigm and Fresh Perspectives. ” Journal of Services Research. Vol. 7, No. 1, pp. 20-44.

Parasuraman, A. , Valarie A. Z. , and Leonard L. B. ( 1985 ) , “ A Conceptual Model of Service Quality and Its Deductions for Future Research, ” Journal of Marketing, Vol. 49, pp. 41-50.

Parasuraman. A, Zeithaml. V. , and Berry. L. ( 1988 ) , “ SERVQUAL: A Multiple-Item Scale for Measuring Consumer Perceptions of Service Quality. ” Journal of Retailing. Vol. 64, No.1, pp. 12-40.

Porter, M.E. ( 1980 ) . Competitive Scheme: Techniques for Analyzing Industries and Rivals, New York, NY: Free Press.

Shostack, G.L ( 1977 ) . “ Breaking free from Merchandise Selling ” Journal of Marketing. Vol. 41, No. 2, pp. 73-80.

Zeithaml, V. A. , Bitner, M. J. ( 2006 ) . Services Selling: Integrating Customer Focus across the Firm. Boston, McGraw-Hill/Irwin.


I'm Amanda

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out