As the most thickly settled state in the universe, the People ‘s Republic of China has been following the One-Child Policy since 1979 in order to better the job of overpopulation which is seen as an obstruction of the growing and development of the state. While the Chinese Government emphasizes its accomplishments of population control in China, the controversial policy has been widely criticized for its negative influences. This paper presents the One-Child Policy ‘s effects on the place of adult females. “ Women ‘s place ” in this paper is fundamentally defined by adult females ‘s rights, freedom, reputability and societal position.I will foremost briefly present the policy, so analyze both the positive and negative impacts with relevant informations and statistics, and in conclusion come to a decision.
The Policy and Population Growth
Introduced in 1978 and implemented since 1979, the One-Child Policy is a household planning policy adopted by the Chinese Government in order to better China ‘s over-rapid population as to forestall its unfavorable effects on economic and societal development of the state. ( Information Office of the State Council Of the People ‘s Republic of China 1995 ) The policy restricts married urban Chinese twosomes from holding more than one kid by enforcing pecuniary punishments on households with excess kids yet freedoms are allowed for twosomes who belong to cultural minorities, live in rural country or do non hold any siblings. ( BBC News 2000 ) The One-Child Policy is considered successful in footings of its control on China ‘s population growing as the birth rate in the county has been greatly diminishing since the debut of the policy. ( see Figure 1 ) “ Compared with 1970, in 1994 the birth rate dropped from 33.43 per 1000 to 17.7 per 1000 ; the natural growing rate, from 25.83 per 1000 to 11.21 per 1000 ; and the entire birthrate rate of adult females, from 5.81 to around 2aˆ¦According to statistics supplied by the United Nations, China ‘s population growing rate has already been markedly lower than the mean degree of other developing states. ” ( Information Office of the State Council Of the People ‘s Republic of China 1995 )
Figure 1. Changes in the entire birthrate rate in China
Beginning: National Population and Family Planning Commission of China ( 2006 )
Misdemeanor of Women ‘s Reproductive Rights
Despite its success in population control, the One-Child Policy gives rise to criticisms among which one lies in its misdemeanor of adult females ‘s generative rights. Generative rights are a subset of human rights foremost recognized at the United Nation ‘s International Conference on Human Rights in Teheran on 13th May 1986. Harmonizing to the 16th article of the Proclamation of Teheran, “ Parents have a basic human right to find freely and responsibly the figure and the spacing of their kids ” . Dixon-Mueller ( 1993: 12 ) suggests that generative rights can be defined as three types: “ 1. the freedom to make up one’s mind how many kids to hold and when ( or whether ) to hold them ; 2. the right to hold the information and means to modulate one ‘s birthrate ; 3. the right to command one ‘s ain organic structure ” . Generative freedom is “ the nucleus of single self-government ” . The One-Child Policy does non merely violate adult females ‘s rights by restricting the figure of their kids but besides leads to coerce abortions in the state. Under the implemented policy, every 2.4 seconds there is a adult female undergoing a forced abortion in China and this makes a sum of about 35,000 abortions per twenty-four hours. ( Phillips 2010: 1 ) Abortion is legal in China and 13 1000000s of abortions are performed in China every twelvemonth, which mostly exceeds those performed in other states such as the United States and Canada. ( see Figure 2 ) . There is a direct relationship between the One-Child Policy and Chine ‘s high abortion rate. Posten & A ; Yaukey ( 1992: 290 ) point out that the abortion rate in China increased by about 50 % between 1978 and 1979 when the policy started being implemented. It is widely known that abortion is harmful to adult females ‘s organic structure, non to advert its negative impacts on their emotional and mental wellness. Ms. Reggie Littlejohn, president of Women ‘s Rights Without Frontiers, criticized that “ The one kid policy causes more force toward adult females and misss than any other policy on the face of the Earth. ” ( Jiang 2009 )
Figure2. Abortion statistics in China, U.S.A. , U.K. , Canada and Australia
Beginning: Jiang ( 2009 )
Unwanted Daughters and Sex-Selective Abortions
A stating among provincials in China goes like this: ” The birth of a male child is welcomed with cries of joy and bangers, but when a miss is born, the neighbors say nil ” ( Westley & A ; Choe 2007: 2 ) In malice of China ‘s modernisation over the past decennaries, it is still common for Chinese people to traditionally prefer boies to girls. ( Wang 1999: 197 ) Such a penchant indirectly leads to sex-selective abortions as female foetuss are normally considered less cherished than male 1s, particularly if the twosome is allowed to hold merely one kid. With foetal testing engineerings such as ultrasound, amniocentesis and chorionic villi sampling, the sex of unborn foetuss can be recognized before their birth. Such engineerings and available abortions result in the possibility that couples selectively abort female foetuss in the hope of holding a boy alternatively. ( Westley & A ; Choe 2007: 3 )
Beside sex-selective abortions, China ‘s infant mortality rate is another thing to look into. By and large the mortality of male babies is expected to be greater than that of female 1s as male babies are biologically weaker than female babies. ( Li, 2007: 2 ) This premise is besides proved by the universe ‘s infant mortality rate by sex. ( see Table 1 ) However, as shown in Table 2, China goes in the rearward way. It is believed that this unusual inclination is caused by female infanticides and girl forsakings ensuing from the combination of the One-Child Policy and boy penchant.
Table 1. World ‘s infant mortality rate by sex 1980-2010
Beginning: United Nations Population Division ( 2010 )
Table 2. China ‘s infant mortality rate by sex 1980-2010
Beginning: United Nations Population Division ( 2010 )
Gender Imbalance – Blessing or Curse?
Together with the increasing female baby mortality, there is a lifting tendency of the sex ratio in China since the implement of the One-Child Policy. ( see Figure 3 ) It is estimated by the State Population and Family Planning Commission that there will be 30 million more Chinese adult male than Chinese adult females in 2020. ( BBC News 2007 )
Because of the supply-and-demand jurisprudence that when supply decreases the value of supply additions, it is assumed that if there are fewer adult females in China, their “ values ” and societal position should of course raise. However, this jurisprudence would do sense merely if the “ demand ” of adult females was high. Poon ( 2008 ) points out that if adult females become the minority of a male-preponderant society ( like China ) , they may confront “ a period of unprecedented male aggression, which would probably render adult females as victims and adult females ‘s position even more unstable and vulnerable to subjection. ” because a rise of adult females ‘s values would profit work forces around them instead than adult females themselves and they would be even more controlled by work forces, hence their place would be even lower.
Figure 3. Rising sex ratio and extra female baby mortality in China
Beginning: Sun ( 2005 )
Women ‘s Empowerment – The Mistaken Focus
It is ever emphasized by the Chinese Government that the One-Child Policy helps advancing adult females ‘s authorization and bettering adult females ‘s place as they are “ freed from heavy loads brought approximately by holding many kids ” ( National Population and Family Planning Commission of China 2006 ) . This claim contains two causal dealingss:
1 ) Because of the One-Child Policy adult females have fewer kids.
2 ) Womans have fewer kids so they can pass more clip on their calling.
Both of them make sense in a big extent, but is the One-Child Policy a must to command the figure of adult females ‘s kids in today ‘s universe?
Despite that Hong Kong is a particular administrative part of the PRC, the One-Child Policy is ne’er implemented in the metropolis, where the societal place of adult females is comparatively high. As shown in Figure 4, the birthrate rate of Hong Kong kept dropping even and was even lower than that of China. Of class one can reason that there are assorted factors lending to Hong Kong ‘s low birthrate rate, yet one can besides oppugn whether the One-Child Policy is the lone factor doing the diminution in birthrate rate and the rise of adult females ‘s place.
Figure 4. Birthrate rates from 1960-2005 in China, Hong Kong, Japan, Korea, Singapore, Taiwan and East Asia & A ; Pacific
Beginning: The United Families International ( 2010 )
The Single Child Generation
The One-Child Policy does non merely take to diminish the birth rate but besides to better the quality of the new coevals, the future pillars of China. It is normally believed that holding individual girls will raise the place of adult females as their parents supply them with better and more concentrated resources such as instruction and stuffs. It may be true in some ways, but Greenhalgh ( 2007. ) points out that the One-Child Policy has produced “ the most materially and educationally privileged coevals of immature people in Chinese history ” who are spoiled and egoistic. “ Having been the focal point of attending from the household throughout their growing-up old ages, these kids are more dependent on others and easy hurt psychologically. “ ( China Daily 2005 ) The Post-80s ( people born in 1980-1989 ) is labeled as “ the Strawberry Generation ( e?‰eZ“?-? ) ” by the imperativeness in China. The term refers to childs who look attractive but are unable to stand any force per unit area and header with failures ( People ‘s Daily Online 2010 ) . It is particularly linked with the single-child coevals as they are normally over-protected by their parents like strawberries in nurseries. This new coevals has already aroused concerns and concerns from the society. Make better resources needfully create a better coevals? If the whole coevals is acquiring worse, how can we anticipate better place of adult females?
The One-Child Policy was claimed to be “ a short-run step ” when it was foremost introduced in China. ( Hesketh, Li & A ; Zhu 2005 ) Now that the policy has already been implemented for three decennaries, although it does hold certain advantages, its negative effects besides finally appear and have aroused concerns from the society. The inhuman policy by and large worsens adult females ‘s place by go againsting adult females ‘s rights and heightening the bing favouritism towards males – and these are non coming to an terminal yet. Harmonizing to the deputy manager of the National Population and Family Planning Commission of China, the state ‘s family-planning policy will stay unchanged until at least 2015. ( Kumar 2010 ) How much longer do Chinese adult females have to endure for their state? Merely the authorities can state.
( 1720 words )