Study On The Conventional Theory History Essay

July 27, 2017 History

The conventional theory towards the Holocaust that I have been taught while turning up was that 6 million Jews died in a period of clip while being oppressed by Hitler and his Nazi followings. Throughout high school I read assorted Holocaust related books including Night, Diary of Ann Frank, and The Hiding Place. I besides watched sympathetic films such as Life is Beautiful. I could non be more grateful to hold learned such a dramatic historical subject in such deepness. However, I am thankless that my high school failed to advert any being of an opposing theory.

After much research I stumbled on a batch of grounds and informations that proves the Holocaust is exaggerated. I want to clearly province, nevertheless, that a tragic decease of a big group of people did happen, and yes, they were oppressed by the greed of one adult male s power. Sadly, my information concludes that merely fewer than 2 million Jews died in concentration cantonments ; whether by gas Chamberss, anguish, being shot, or even natural causes. What I am reasoning is that the figure and extent to which this period of clip has been exploited is false. Basically, 6 million Jews did non decease, and were non shacking at that place to get down with.

Let s get down with 6,500,000 Judaic people in pre-war Europe said to hold been shacking in assorted states. In 1933-1945, 1.5 million Jews emigrated to Britain, Sweden, Spain, Portugal, Australia, China, India, Palestine, and the U.S. This fact was confirmed by Bruno Blau, a Judaic journalist, who cites the same figure in Aufbau, a Judaic Magazine, on August 13, 1948. Of the 1.5 emigrated populations 400,000 came from Germany go forthing 1,100,000 emigres from different European states. After September of 1939, 360,000 is said to be the standing figure of Jews that remained in Germany, Austria, and Czechoslovakia combined. Austria had 220,000 residing in the state with 280,000 Hebrews emigrating, go forthing 60,000 in the state. Sing Czechoslovakia, the Prague Institution for Jewish Emigration welcomed 260,000 Jews from the state.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

Poland was a conflict field of statements as to a believable figure of shacking and emigrating Jews. Many Jews from Poland didn T lawfully emigrate and alternatively were countless blowouts. This gives the conventional theory some room to add a twosome more dead organic structures to the Holocaust. Prior to the eruption of War, 500,000 fled from Poland. Entire figure of Judaic emigres from other European states ( eastern ) was 120,000. This hegira was before and during belligerencies go forthing about 5 million Jews in Europe wholly.

After 1939 Jews fled to Soviet Union before the Germans invaded. 1,250,000 were from Poland while 300,000 were European Jews that slipped into the Soviet district ( the blowout ) , Reitlinger admits. Get downing out with 5 million Jews shacking in Europe with 1.55 million Jews go forthing flying to the Soviet Union, we remain with 3,450,000 Hebrews populating in Europe pre war.

On a side note, the 1942 World Almanac claims that in Gibraltar, Britain, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Ireland, and Turkey combined there are 413,128 Jews. I would see the World Almanac to be a dependable beginning, but I ll stick with the 3,450,000 Jews statement merely for fluidness in this essay.

Let s non halt at 3 million. Most of the Jews that fled to the Soviet Union were Polish.

History claims that 3 million Polish Jews were exterminated in the war. However, 1931 Judaic Population Census for Poland was 2,732,600 of which 1,170,000 were in Russian occupied district in fall of 1939. When we subtract this figure along with the 500,000 that emigrated from Poland prior to the war we end up with 1,062,600 Hebrews left in the state of Poland. Compare this figure to the 3 million history claims were exterminated.

Now that we have the sum of Polish Jews in Europe and the figure of Jews life in Germany, Austria, and Czech, 360,000 all together, I would wish to add these Numberss together to come up with a close sum of Jews shacking in Europe. We end up with 1,422,600 aside from the 120,000 Gallic Hebrews that were deported during the Nuremberg Trials into Europe. With all these Numberss added we end up at 1,542,600 which is still fewer than 2 million Jews in Europe. When we add the remainder of Europe s Judaic population with states including Holland, Belgium, Italy, and Romania, the entire figure of Jews shacking in Europe prior to the war is 2,952,500.

However, typical to any confederacy theory, there is an opposing side to the narrative. The count of Russian Jews emigrating in and out of Europe is questionable. Western Russia was invaded by the Germans and in 1939 there were 2,100,000 Jews life at that place harmonizing to Louis Levine, President of American Jewish Council for Russian Relief. However, the bulk of these Jews evacuated to Eastern Russia after the Germans launched their invasion.

At the beginning of war, Jews were amongst the first evacuated from the western parts threatened by Hitlerite encroachers, and shipped to safety East of the Urals. 2 million Jews were saved, said Louis Levine on October 30, 1946. Besides, the New York Times stated that there were 6 million Jews life in Europe aside from the ( about 3 million ) residing in Russia. With these facts, the figure of Jews in Europe shoots up to about 8 million.

However, in 2003, the count of subsisters of the Holocaust was 1,092,000 significance around 1945 there had to hold been about 5 times as many, sing deceases from natural causes and other things over the 65 old ages. This brings us to 3 million casualties no sing the 100s of 1000s of Jews emigrating.

In decision, even with other beginnings saying different Numberss, there still could non hold been more than 2 million casualties in the Holocaust. Yes, the Holocaust was a calamity to the Judaic population and it is really annihilating that 1000000s of people died because of their faith ethnicity. However, the one thing that I am oppugning throughout this essay is, does this event in history earn the rubric of being called a Holocaust when there are so many other wars and subjugations that surpass this calamity with casualty Numberss?

x

Hi!
I'm Amanda

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out