The Unreasonableness of Animal Testing Essay

September 28, 2017 Medical

Professor Charles R. Magel has stated. “Ask the experimenters why they experiment on animate beings. and the reply is: ‘Because the animate beings are like us. ’ Ask the experimenters why it is morally All right to experiment on animate beings. and the reply is: ‘Because the animate beings are non like us. ’ Animal experimentation remainders on a logical contradiction ( “Animal Testing 101” ) . ” Besides. in actuality. animate beings are non like us given that there are assorted biological unsimilarities between worlds and animate beings. doing it perfectly unreasonable to compare worlds with animate beings.

As an illustration. morphia is supposed to quiet human existences. but it excites cats. Cortisone does non do birth defects in worlds ; it merely does so in mice. Penicillin can kill guinea hogs and hamsters. and acetylsalicylic acid can poison cats and do foetal malformations in rats. Digitalis is used by human bosom patients. but raises the blood force per unit area of Canis familiariss. Had worlds relied on the consequences of experiments conducted on carnal topics. they would non hold discovered the benefits of penicillin to worlds. nor the life salvaging value of digitalin to those people who are enduring from bosom disease.

They would ne’er hold known the common anaesthetic they now know as trichloromethane either. seeing that it is toxic to Canis familiariss. Many steroids. epinephrine. insulin. and certain antibiotics are besides harmful to animate beings albeit medically good for world ( “Animal Experimentation” ) . All the same. many scientists continue to believe in the importance of carnal proving. Their beliefs are evidently non taking modern scientific research into consideration.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Despite the research studies on the unreasonableness of carnal experimentation. about one hundred and 15 million animate beings are still being experimented on and subsequently killed in the research labs of U. S. experimenters twelvemonth after twelvemonth ( “Animal Testing 101” ) . Of these animate beings. 2 to 4 million are being used in safety proving entirely ( “Animal Testing. ” 2007 ) . Yet. it is unlogical for scientists to utilize animate beings for research that is meant to profit chiefly worlds. One can non differ with the fact that it is good for worlds to larn more about the animate beings who occupy the planet with them. merely as it is good for them to cognize about the other planets of the solar system. the stars. the nebulas and dark affair in the universe.

There are general benefits of cognition realized by all those who possess it. In the yesteryear. carnal experimentation has helped worlds to derive more cognition. After all. it is through their failed research with drugs utilizing animate beings that they have come to recognize that animate beings differ from them biologically. Therefore. experimenters should non travel frontward with such research.

Human intelligence is to larn from errors. even if a error is made merely one time. There is no ground to set animate beings to torment by giving them harmful medical specialties. subsequently to detect that those medical specialties are really good for worlds. Countless animate beings are abused in the research labs of experimenters. Two carnal proving research labs exist within my little community entirely. Peoples that care kick to PETA about it continuously ( “Animal Testing 101” ) .

Scientists had been utilizing rats for malignant neoplastic disease research before it was reported in the twelvemonth 1993 that utilizing rats for malignant neoplastic disease research is basically unpointed given that the cistron fix system of rats makes them remarkably susceptible to malignant neoplastic disease. In other words. there are important differences in the manner the cistrons of gnawers and worlds are repaired ( “Animal Experimentation” ) .

Although this fact is out – one could anticipate that scientists who give in to unlogical theories may go on to utilize rats for malignant neoplastic disease research. To halt the scientists from mislaying our valuable resources – fundss. in add-on to the ecological advantages of animate beings – the authorities should step frontward and put an terminal to animal experimentation wholly. Animal testing is clearly unreasonable. and there is no ground to reason about it any longer.


Animal Experiment: Cruel and Unnecessary. Retrieved October 18. 2007. from

hypertext transfer protocol: //members. iinet. cyberspace. au/~rabbit/aniexp. htm.

Animal Testing 101.Stop Animal Trials.Retrieved October 18. 2007. from

hypertext transfer protocol: //www. stopanimaltests. com/animalTesting101. asp.

Animal Testing. ( 2007 ) . The Human Society of the United States. Retrieved October 18. 2007.

from hypertext transfer protocol: //www. hsus. org/animals_in_research/animal_testing/ .


I'm Amanda

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out